When the Virtual Upstages the Real

A woman working on a laptop computer, using social media.

Social media has become the primary conduit for criticizing others, airing our gripes and mobilizing against real and perceived injustices. It’s basically where we go to ‘do something’ when we find matters in the world are amiss: we resort to the seeming quick fix that the internet offers.

But like all technologies that have arisen throughout the course of history, the internet is also a double-edged sword. It’s changed how we engage with life, exacting a sort of Faustian “price” we pay in exchange for its benefits. As Robert Ornstein and James Burke showed in their classic 1997 book, The Axemaker’s Gift: Technology’s Capture and Control of Our Minds and Culture, new gains are offset by the aspects of life that are replaced by a new technology.

For example, the invention of the automobile, although conferring incredible benefits on our ability to travel and cover distances easily and quickly, has dealt a serious blow to the time immemorial human act of walking—especially for longer distances. We can see the consequences of this, in the United States for example, where many things from architecture and city planning to people’s health have been affected.

One of the more obvious costs of the internet and social media  is that we spend large parts of our days distracted and entranced by screens. Virtual relationships and communication online are quickly coming to replace real life social contacts with all that comes with it: physical cues, body language, the benefits of in person contact, the sharing of real physical experiences. There are likely a flurry of other negative consequences that lie just below conscious awareness and that will become apparent as this technology is seized and further developed. One of them, which just occurred to me,  is  that by increasingly taking our concerns online, we are likely preempting—or robbing the real world of—other more direct forms of action we could be taking around an issue. And not just through amount of time we spend online versus out in the world.

Could it be that when we campaign, lobby or complain in the virtual world we are in fact discharging the impulse to act in the real, physical world, where our efforts and the impact are seemingly more tangible? We feel less compelled to act after posting online because we’ve gotten that hit of satisfaction that comes with feeling that we’ve done our bit. It may also be that by commenting online, even when we get much response and feedback, we are under the illusion that we’ve done something when in fact, we mostly haven’t.

As time goes on we will likely uncover more unintended consequences of these new technologies that we embrace, and which might have a serious negative impact on what previously defined us as human.